debate forum

[ranjeet_rp]

yo india community is now not only a forum for poets but we can discuss anything in "chit chat and general disscussion" forum. I suggest a forum for debate where two authers debate on any perticuler topic,and each of them get four rounds of 1500(more or less)words to say anything in aggrement or disagreement to that topic.All other readers will post their comments thereafter.please comment to this suggession.

[iAdmin]

New suggestions are alwasy appreciated and you have come with a nice one.
But do you really think that we need separate forum for it ? Or if we do make separate forum, will it be active enough ?
Though, we can have FORUM like "RANT HOUSE" where people can just debate on things. Can be current affairs, can be their view regarding various thing..etc.

But in the end, we don't want just new forum on Yoindia which remain dull forever !

Other people, kindly comment !

[javedarshad]

Hi

u do not need a new forum,It is not necessary that everyone is going on saperate one . So U can discuss and debate anything under this banner.
Beside this I will advice that everyone has to remember that this is a public place,u might or u might not be agree with others opinion,comments or views.No aggressive mood or personnal attack will be acceptable.
Be humble and in good manners u must ask and give suggestion opinion and documentary proof to relate any view or qoute to the subject.

This is good suggestion. It will give knowledge and keep u updated in so many respects . This discussion may be on adab , personnal problems,samajic achaiyan aur buraiyan,mazahib and any auspect of life.
But no p. attack or hard feeling.




Tx





javed

[iAdmin]

So, as per Javed Ji view, we do not need new Forum ie. New section on Yoindia Shayariadab. Lets wait what others have to say about it.

Thankyou!

[Talat]

I too agree with Javed. Though, such discussions are good (as long as they are with few defined lines), there is no need for a separate forum for this.

[dead heart]

hmm i do not agree with javed ji...sorry to say...i think the debate forum wuld b a gud one...a gud place to put opinions...argue..reasons...i wuld highly agree with it...

the only thing that i dnt agree with is the limit of four rounds and 1500 words...i think the limit shuld b of days like 10-15 days...in which ppl cn put their reasons...opinions...and then the "judge"(which i think is a gud idea...there shuld b a judge either the person who is puttin in the idea of the debate or the admin--according to u ppl and ur votes) cn give a final decision according to him/her....hmm the other thing is the person puttin in the debate cn not put any opinion or reason...he/she will read all the posts and views and if that person is said to b judge..then he/she will igve his/her final decision on the last day of that debate....

anyone can argue on the motion...ppl have to say whether they propose or oppose the motion before entering the debate and if they are opposing sumthn...they have to mention clearly wat they r opposing plus who said sumthn that they dnt agree with...if they fail to do dat..they cn even be told to not post any other comment on that debate by the judge....

ppl may b allowed to use facts and live examples from the world today...no objection shuld b raised on this that y did u say this(y on this country or on this leader)..its shuld b freedom of speech completely...


i think i have said jst too much but in the end, however, is till say that i agree with this forum highly and i am lookin forward to this forum...

nice idea ranjeet ji

[sajid_ghayel]

yes yes and a big yes for this forum i completely understand what ranjeet is trying to do here he is trying to bring people from various intrest to one platform. well my only concern is such forum should not overshadowed the work of good shayers or they start feeling alien in yoindia. we should never ever forget that shayri is the heart of yo india.

[khushi4all]

Agree...!!! 

no need of diff forum... diff section or diff topic is enough....

 

[baadal102]

i agree with javed & celmira ji



Baadal

[salil2002]

what i think is tht .........we r here to know more abt shayaris
.............so plzzz don't add new forum and let this site for shayaris only .........

[honeyrose]

Yes as friends suggest i too feel we dont need to add a new forum

as this site is specially for shayaris would like to maintain

its beauty as the same way...i agree with Celmira sis,,javed ji..

[harashmahajan]

Dear Admin ji...I just came online and saw this pm of yours......though I have no time to read the reviews already given by other members...but feel necessary to put forth mine here for the well being of Our family site.It may affect to make a valuable decision...

In my opinion its worthless to put such form as it will become a messener to join and to discuss personal matters and the poets will be disturbed by the impact of their talks ultimately there will be a "Jung Maidaan" and our very purpose of the forum as shayari will be defeated....instead we should start a thread to discuss the pros n cons of the rules of shayries or the things related to it and poetry to implement. Our Primary motive of the Forum to produce good poets and Ghazal writers...


Thanks


Harash[/color]

[sajid_ghayel]

well even though i have given my view in favour of the forum i also do agree with what harsh have said everything is going just fine and we should leave as it is.

Dear Admin ji...I just came online and saw this pm of yours......though I have no time to read the reviews already given by other members...but feel necessary to put forth mine here for the well being of Our family site.It may affect to make a valuable decision...

In my opinion its worthless to put such form as it will become a messener to join and to discuss personal matters and the poets will be disturbed by the impact of their talks ultimately there will be a "Jung Maidaan" and our very purpose of the forum as shayari will be defeated....instead we should start a thread to discuss the pros n cons of the rules of shayries or the things related to it and poetry to implement. Our Primary motive of the Forum to produce good poets and Ghazal writers...


Thanks


Harash[/color]

[Azeem Azaad]

Achcha Hai,.
I Too Thought So,.
But Couldnt Express It Here,.
Thanx Ranjit Bhai Ke Aapne Hamari Dil Ki Baat Yahaan Bataa Di,.

Agar Ye Forum Open Hua To Bahoot Faida Hoga,.
Inshallah,.

[abdbundeli]

Mr iAdmin!
If the purpose of the proposed FORUM is genuine LITERARY CRITICISM, away from religious discourses or the so called taktreers, such a FORUM will be a BOON to YOINDIA. If you want me to give my frank opinion, THE RELIGIOUS MATTERS MUST NOT BE DISCUSSED IN ANY LITERARY FORUMS at all, except when some-body is commenting on 'NAATS' or 'BHAJANS'. What I've seen, some members, start citing 'religious truths(?)' rather than their Literary Values. It, however, can not be denied, that, most the SCRIPTURES are also literary creations of a very high order; but then only their LITERARY HEIGHTS (or even weaknesses) should be discussed, not their religious heights.
Regards
R.P.GARG (abd bundeli)