Provision for New forum.. User's view invited.

[Ricky]

idea acha hai, magar jayada success hoga yah najar nahi atta!! may be shuru mai kuch post mai log likh bhi de, baad mai har koi apni post likhana chahta hai aor apne dosto ki post ka jawab dena chahta hai!!! yah sirf mere views hai.

May be kuch dedicated ppl isse chalaty rahe!!!

Well.. ya we need some dedication in beginning..
People may post their old shayari also there get its xplanation from others as earlier they were posted and have jugalbandi in it but now no jugalbandi.. rather only appreciation and that only with explanation.

Still not much people have seen this thread, I request Yoindian to encourage their other Yoindian friends to give their views over here.

[Saba_Saba]

Idea bohat achha hai.... but as said by Pooja ... sab apni post aur reply me uljhe rehte hai... but i will definetely write on this

waiting for it....

[BeNam]

I think it will get people into conflicts, if you get an explaination in completely wrong manner people can get offended. As a thought to be shared I think it would be great if we open up a region where a topic will be thrown by the monitor and every one starts contributing as a question answer kind of shayari. This is just a suggestion. Where in you communicate the message in the form of shayari!

BENAM

[Ricky]

As a thought to be shared I think it would be great if we open up a region where a topic will be thrown by the monitor and every one starts contributing as a question answer kind of shayari. This is just a suggestion. Where in you communicate the message in the form of shayari!

BENAM

I think this is already the trend at Yoindia. Infact there are various thread at Yoindia where we are already doing "Talk in Shayari" .May be I am getting it wrong so.. if you want you can explain it more clearly.

I think it will get people into conflicts, if you get an explaination in completely wrong manner people can get offended.

Well, there will be some guidelines there according to which people have to move on, ie.. post it on your own risk but I think if the explanation will be totally wrong then It will be better for author as then he /she will know exactly where he / she is lacking.

[bhambra]

Bhamvra:
Well. . making sepearate section for each langage is not possible becasuse there are many languages but not sure about how many users are there for that language ..Also.. each language will have its own dard section, fun section etc.. so i don't think it this way we can give full justification to any language. But don't worry.. your idea is noted down.

Thanx Ricky, aapne mera post pe gaur farmaya...par u r not getting me...look...main bol raha hu k forum baas ek hi ho like"Regional Forum" ya smth like that...usme hum ek ek lang k liye sirf ek hi threat khol sakte hay, aab jaise ki ek bangali threat ho gaya, usme jitne bhi bengali poems hum likhte hay wo post kar sakte hay, kaisi bhi poem ho, like dard, funny, kuch bhi aapne creations, har ek lang. k liye sirf ek hi threat. so yahan aise kayi frnds hay jo aapne aapne lang me kuch likhte ho, par unke liye koi khaas forums nahi hay. Un frnds ko yeh forum ek naya inspiration de sakegi.
Aur jaisi k aap bol rahe the ek forum k liye, like pooja and saba mujhe bhi lagta hay k yeh forum kuch khaas nahi hoga, kuch din baad usme bhi sab apne apne jugalbandi shuru kar denge. Lets see, hamare dusre frnds kya bolte hay.....

[Ricky]

Well, your idea of making forum for different language is good, don't worry we have noted. BTW.. going exactly your way is practical, that will only ruin the accent of Yoindia.  Rather we will discuss this stuff in different thread and we will come up with your idea but with also a better way.

About "Explanation by the Readers" ..I thought this as new name. Let see inputs from other memebers too. Uptill now very few members have seen it.

[friend4u_eversmile]

good....this is very nice...as thousand of ppl know yoindia and there are thousands of active member too......so it is a good move.

[Talat]

Sorry for being late !!!

The idea is definitely good !! When we write something and we post here, normally we get appreciation..and responses in the form of shayari as well...but it will be even nicer if we can know if the readers are getting the same feeling what we had when we wrote that poetry !!! or how much they are understanding...!! and it will be a good initiative as views from people may even help to make it (the poetry) even better !!!

I agree there should be a separate forum for this purpose, wholely dedicated to this kind of postings.

As far as poor response is concerned, there is nothing wrong in experimenting..and u never know if it indeed attracts the members and turns out to be a good step...!!!

[ranjeet_rp]

its a good idea,poets will not only get appriciation but also critical review of their poems.although it will take much of the space so i personaly think that in this thread only self written poems should be allowed.

[badnaam_shayar]

idea acha hai, magar jayada success hoga yah najar nahi atta!! may be shuru mai kuch post mai log likh bhi de, baad mai har koi apni post likhana chahta hai aor apne dosto ki post ka jawab dena chahta hai!!! yah sirf mere views hai.

May be kuch dedicated ppl isse chalaty rahe!!!

Well.. ya we need some dedication in beginning..
People may post their old shayari also there get its xplanation from others as earlier they were posted and have jugalbandi in it but now no jugalbandi.. rather only appreciation and that only with explanation.

Still not much people have seen this thread, I request Yoindian to encourage their other Yoindian friends to give their views over here.

Ya you both are right ricky bhai and pooja sis.......but aap yeh kyun nahi sochte ki sab ek dusre ko dekh k aayenge..........aap shuru toh karo is forum ko.........phir dekhte hain.......main toh jaroor post karunga.........i m waiting......

[Soheb_Khan]

Even I think thats its not required
it will only add increase the no. of forums making the usability a "litttle" more complicated
anyway the appreciations are included in the threads
Cheers

[Bharat]

Hi Ricky,
I have read everybody's views. My thinking is very similar to Pooja.
I agree with Pooja 100%.
What I think is the people will reply/take time/put an effort to only writers who are very popular and longtime Yoindians.
I mean friend will reply to friends.
I do not think the new members and people who do not come often will get much attention.
It is like rich will get richer.........
I sincerely hope that I am wrong and this forum (if it is added) will be a success.     Anyway, I will participate..........
It is only my opinion..........

Bharat

[Ricky]

I am totally amazed that what a point people are raising that only friends will answer friends. but I think those who will post thier poem for critics will also give critics to other because of feeling that.. "What you get now is all what you gave ones" ...
But still that fourm is not added as more people's view are expected.

[mili_genie]

Mujhe lagta hay yeh bahot jyada asardaar nahi hoga, kiu k dure forums me bhi hum apne creations k baareme dusre viewer se jaan sakte hay, i think yoindia need a REGIONAL BASE forum....jisme har language k liye ek hi forma rahega, you cannot add more than one for a particuler lang. Like punjabi ka ek, bengali ka ek, etc. So wahan hamare jaise jo aapne lang. me bhi thora bahot likhte hay kuch post kar sake....

Well yeh sirf mere idea thi, i will accept wht you people decide...
Thank you...

yes souvanik dada ur absolutly right...

[sohail azad]

YES.

This will be a great idea and will give oppertunity to improve our ability also.

Well great Idea to to explain our opinions about new writers.

Just start this forum ASAP!

Kind regards.

Sohail Azad.
Pakistan